WD My Passport Ultra vs. Seagate Backup Plus Slim – Which portable external hard drive is better?

0
220

Seagate and Western Digital are two of the most reputable manufacturers of external storage in the market. This review aims to take an in-depth look at the Western Digital My Passport Ultra and the Seagate Backup Plus Slim to discover their differences and similarities.

Every computer and laptop requires a backup hard drive that allows you to store or backup large amounts of data efficiently and is ready to accompany you wherever you go. Western Digital and Seagate both offer a wide range of high-quality portable external hard drives with different connectivity and capacity specifications. This guide has narrowed down to Western Digital My Passport Ultra and Seagate Backup Plus Slim, which are two premium quality external portable hard drives, perfect for all your storage needs. WD My Passport Ultra is a colorful option with wireless connectivity and easy-to-access digital media, while Seagate Backup Plus Slim has more storage capacity points. Let us take a look at the specifics of each device to find out which reigns supreme.

What are the differences between WD My Passport Ultra and Seagate Backup Plus Slim?

Model name
Western Digital My Passport Ultra
Seagate Backup Plus Slim
Design
Compact, light and sturdy design with dimensions of 0.5 by 4.33 by 3.21 inches and a mass weight of 8 ounces
Available in multiple colors and has dimensions of 0.81 by 3.07 by 4.51 inches with a mass weight of 8.5 ounces
Capacity
500GB, 1TB, 2TB, and 4TB
500GB, 1TB, 2TB, 4TB, and 5TB
Performance
It uses the OEM and has a read/write speed of 128Mbps and 123Mbps respectively
It uses the ST2000LM007 drive and has a read/write speed of 120Mbps

WD My Passport Ultra vs. Seagate Backup Plus Slim – How do they compare?

Design

WD My Passport Ultra is a compact and lightweight drive that measures 0.5 by 4.33 by 3.21 inches. It comes in a compact polycarbonate shell with a smooth feel and a sturdy enclosure and is available in multiple colors, including Wild Berry, Noble Blue, Classic Black, and Brilliant White. The color covers the top face of the drive’s shell while its sides remain matte black. There is also a white activity light on the drive that indicates when it is idle, in standby, or active, as well as a USB 3.0 port.

Alternatively, the Backup Plus Slim from Seagate is available in multiple colors; black, blue, silver, and red, up to the 2TB capacity drive, while its 4TB drive is only available in black. These portable drives are among the thinnest drivers in the market, but they do not have a similar thickness. Those up to 2TB are 0.5 inches thick, while the 4TB is slighter thicker at 0.8 inches. The drive also features an aluminum casing that is quite light and solid. It has a utilitarian design and has a mass weight of 8.5 ounces.

WD My Passport Ultra is, therefore, a more visually attractive and lighter external SSD as it comes in multiple attractive colors than the Seagate Backup Plus Slim.

Capacity

Western Digital My Passport Ultra comes in three capacity points of 500GB, 1TB, 2TB, 3TB, and 4TB, which is adequate for storing the backup data of most desktops and laptops. It can comfortably hold a couple hundred thousand photos, thousands of movies and audio files, as well as any document you have ever written. The drive is also quite affordable, given its capacity range.

On the other hand, Seagate’s Backup Plus Slim comes in multiple storage sizes of 500GB, 1TB, 2TB, 4TB, and 5TB. It can backup data from your laptop, desktop, phone, and well as your social networking accounts. However, it is more expensive than the My Passport Ultra, owing to its larger storage space.

Seagate Backup Plus Slim is, therefore, more versatile in relation to storage space, than WD My Passport Ultra as it comes in up to 5TB.

Performance

Theoretically, WD My Passport Ultra has read/write speeds of 128Mbps and 123Mbps, respectively, and uses an OEM drive. It is formatted for NTFS, meaning you will have to reformat it for use with MAC OS. The drive also comes with bundled software, which includes drive monitoring programs, backup utility, and 256-bit hardware encryption. Its backup utility allows you to automatically save copies of your documents to your Dropbox account, provided you have a paid account. Its hardware encryption is disabled by default, but you can easily enable it by using the included utility. Just make sure your password is safe and easy to remember.

Due to its generous space and USB 3.0 interface, the Seagate Backup Plus Slim has read/write speed of 120Mbps. It also has bundled software, including the Mylio photo management software and a two-month subscription to Adobe Creative Cloud. The drive is NTFS-formatted, meaning you will have to reformat it to HFS+ to use it on MAC OS with Time Machine, but it directly allows you to back up your data from a Windows PC. The drive also supports USB 3.0 via a detachable 18-inch cable, available in its packaging.

WD My Passport Ultra is, therefore, a faster external SSD than Seagate Backup Plus Slim as it offers a theoretical sequential read and write speed of 128/123Mbps.

WD My Passport Ultra vs. Seagate Backup Plus Slim –A Comparison Overview

WD My Passport Ultra

The Passport Ultra range from Western Digital is one of the best portable external hard drives available in the market. Available in sizes 500GB, 1TB, 2TB, 3TB, and 4TB, it features 256-bit AES hardware encryption for ensuring your files are safe, cloud storage, as well as Western Digital’s own bundled software.

It has a compact and lightweight design and is available in multiple colors. The drive is affordable and has reasonable read/write speeds of 128Mbps and 123Mbps, respectively. It also comes with a lengthy 3-year warranty and is an excellent backup device for anyone who requires plenty of portable storage. You can purchase Grip packs at an extra cost to customize the drive to your aesthetics at an additional cost.

Pros

  • Great storage capacity
  • Lengthy three-year warranty
  • 256-bit hardware encryption for security
  • It comes with bundled software

Cons

  • Its plastic case does not feel durable

 

View price on Amazon

 

Seagate Backup Plus Slim

If you are looking for a thin, spacious and fast external portable hard drive, the Seagate Backup Plus Slim is an ideal option. Not only is it a convenient means of storing all the files from your laptop and the media from your social networking accounts and phone, but also given that its top capacity is 5TB, the storage gap between a desktop and a portable drive is no longer an issue.

This external portable hard drive is available in five capacity points, including 500GB, 1TB, 2TB, 4TB, and 5TB. The drive features a minimalist metal enclosure and comes with a USB 3.0 cable that allows you to easily back up file either via automatic scheduling or with a single click. It is compatible with both Windows and MAC; however, you will need to reformat it when you want to use it with Time Machine. It also comes with a 2-year warranty and a two-month subscription to Adobe Creative Cloud Photography Plan.

Pros

  • Compact and pocket-sized drive
  • An excellent per-Gigabyte price tag
  • Backup all the files in your laptop and the media files in your phone and social networking accounts
  • Compatible with Windows and MAC
  • Great file transfer speed
  • It comes with bundled software, including Adobe Creative Cloud and Mylio Create

Cons

  • Limited two-year warranty
  • It does not have the Universal Storage Module ( USM) Interface

 

View price on Amazon

 

Conclusion

Both of these two drives are both top quality external portable hard drives that will meet all your storage needs. The WD My Passport Ultra features a 256-bit AES hardware encryption to secure your files as well as adequate storage space for all your data. Alternatively, Seagate Backup Plus Slim delivers fast file transfer speeds and greater storage space than your average hard drive.

Final verdict: So, which is better between WD My Passport Ultra and Seagate Backup Plus Slim?

WD My Passport Ultra and Seagate Backup Plus Slim have a few similarities. For instance, they both have excellent storage capacity and come with various bundled software. However, when it comes down to it, the Seagate Backup Plus Slim is highly recommended due to its fast speed and impressive storage capacity. If you frequently travel and never leave your laptop behind, this option is definitely a great buy due to its fast speed and compact size.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the external portable hard drive work with PS4?

Excluding the 4TB versions and above, the smaller versions of 2TB, 1TB, and 500GB are compatible with PS4 once you manually remove them from their enclosure to ensure it fits.

What is the difference between WD My Passport and WD My Passport Ultra?

Compared to MY Passport, My Passport Ultra comes in a thinner, smaller, and a more comfortable to handle size. It also has a more durable and aesthetically-pleasing metal cover in an innovative style.

Mathew Cain

Mathew Cain has been working in the IT industry for over 10 years and is well versed with the problems that many people experience and are not accorded comprehensive and reliable information to help solve them. The primary function of a central processing unit is to store and retrieve information fast, but this is rarely the case if the unit has a small storage and processing capacity. And that is why Data Storage Guide has decided to give back the power to the user, by providing them with the most current and reliable information. You will, therefore, find information on the various storage devices and how best you can retrieve your lost data and also get rid permanently of sensitive information.